From Ballads to Boogie: Did the Bee Gees ever aspire to become Disco Legends?

The Twelve Inch 141 : You Should Be Dancing (Bee Gees)

A Personal Introduction to the Bee Gees Phenomenon

Growing up, the Bee Gees felt like the biggest band in the world. They were everywhere. 3 men with long waiving hair, clad in pants, so tight they must have hurt, and shiny satin shirts that were unbuttoned to a point where you almost saw their belly button. The Saturday Night Fever soundtrack was terrorizing every possible turntable on this planet and the movie was box-office gold. Not that you’d hear me complain. As a disco kid, I was all in.

But when I first heard their earlier music—hits from the ’60s and early ’70s—it was a different sound entirely. It left me wondering: “Why did the Bee Gees shift so dramatically to disco?” and “When exactly did that transformation happen?” This week, I explore these questions through their third U.S. number-one hit, “You Should Be Dancing,” and the pivotal era when the Bee Gees reinvented themselves.

The Bee Gees’ Early Years: From Ballads to Breakups

The Bee Gees’ journey began in the ’60s, shaped by their British-Australian roots. After early success in Australia with “Spicks & Specks,” the brothers returned to England in 1966, signed with manager Robert Stigwood, and quickly became a force in pop music. Hits like “New York Mining Disaster 1941,” “Holiday,” and “To Love Somebody” cemented their reputation as chart-toppers on both sides of the Atlantic.

The Bee Gees with Robert Stigwood

However, by 1969, tensions arose during the release of their Odessa album, leading to Robin’s brief departure. Although they reunited, their progressive rock phase in the early ’70s struggled to find commercial success. It was only after moving to America and working with producer Arif Mardin at Miami’s Criteria Studios that their sound began to evolve.

A New Era: The Miami Influence and Arif Mardin

The turning point came in 1974 with the Mr. Natural album, marking their first collaboration with Mardin. While the album wasn’t a hit, it laid the groundwork for 1975’s Main Course. This album delivered their second U.S. number one, “Jive Talkin’,” The follow up single “Nights On Broadway” introduced us to another hallmark of the late seventies Bee Gees sound : the falsetto.

The Bee Gees with Arif Mardin.

Overcoming Setbacks: How the Bee Gees Perfected Their Sound and Scored a Hit

Buoyed by the success of Main Course, the Bee Gees set out to record their next album, Children of the World, with producer Arif Mardin. However, their plans took an unexpected turn when Robert Stigwood, their manager, shifted the distribution of his label, RSO, from Atlantic Records to Polydor. This move created a major hurdle: Mardin, signed exclusively to Atlantic, could no longer work with the group.

The brothers were stunned—Mardin had been instrumental in their resurgence. After an unproductive two-day trial with producer Richard Perry, they decided to take matters into their own hands. Drawing on the expertise of Albhy Galuten and Karl Richardson, the engineers from Main Course, the Bee Gees re-created and refined the sound Mardin had helped establish.

The Birth of “You Should Be Dancing”

Released in 1976, “You Should Be Dancing” marked a bold step into disco. With its driving beat, infectious falsetto, and layered production, it captured the energy of the dance floor. The song’s conga rhythms, dramatic synthesizers, and even a hard-rocking guitar solo showcased their genre-blending prowess.

Lyrically, it’s pure dance-floor escapism, urging listeners to move to the groove. Its success was undeniable: entering the Billboard Hot 100 at #67, it climbed to #1 within nine weeks. Barry Gibb would later in an interview confirm that they didn’t really know if the track would be a sure shot : Well I don’t think you can ever say that about any song. I think you can look at each other and go, “this is great. This is special.” Whether it’s chart special or radio special, this was special for us. I have said before that I think Islands In The Stream struck us as a number one record, before anyone recorded it. So sometimes you really feel it. I really felt it with How Deep Is Your Love and we were just having a great time with You Should Be Dancing because suddenly everyone was wanting to dance and we wanted to make a record like that. So I think it was us doing that.

This track cemented the Bee Gees’ role as disco pioneers, later featuring on the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack where it sat perfectly alongside “Stayin’ Alive” and “Night Fever.”

---

Welcome, I’m Pe Dupre and this is “The Twelve Inch”, a newsletter that tells the history of dance music between 1975 and 1995, one twelve inch at a time.

If you’ve received this newsletter, then you either subscribed or someone forwarded it to you. If you fit into the latter and want to subscribe, please do so. That way you will not miss a single episode.

---

Why the Bee Gees’ Shift Wasn’t So Sudden

While it may seem like a sharp pivot, the Bee Gees’ move to disco was more evolutionary than revolutionary. Their hallmark harmonies and intricate arrangements always had R&B undertones—“To Love Somebody” was originally written for Otis Redding. Even their 1970 track “IOIO” hinted at the four-on-the-floor beat that would dominate disco.

Arif Mardin didn’t create something entirely new with the Bee Gees; he amplified what was already there. This helps explain why they never saw themselves as strictly “disco artists.” Unlike many of their contemporaries, they didn’t rely on remixes or extended versions of their hits, yet they still achieved massive success, including scoring a big number one (7 weeks) in the Billboard dance charts. It was, surprisingly, their only number one in the dance charts

Cultural Impact and Timelessness

“You Should Be Dancing” transcended its era, becoming a symbol of the Bee Gees’ influence on pop culture. While others tried to reinterpret it—like the Salsoul Orchestra and Gene Page—none matched the original’s magic. Even their own 1993 house remix for Size Isn’t Everything lacked the infectious energy of the 1976 hit.

An interesting question that I will not go into in this episode is, who influenced who when Robert Stigwood bought the rights to an article “Tribal Rights Of The New Saturday Night” and decided to make the first disco movie with The Bee Gees delivering (a big part of) the score. Would he have bought the rights even without the success of “Jive Talkiin’” and “You Should Be Dancing” and the move of the band he managed into danceable R&B?

The Bee Gees’ move to dance music wasn’t just about following trends; it was about creating timeless art. Their contribution to Saturday Night Fever didn’t just define disco—it reshaped the soundscape of the late ’70s and influenced generations of artists.

What Comes Next

The Bee Gees soared higher than almost anyone in the music world, but their meteoric rise came with a price. Much like Icarus, they flew too close to the sun. The story of their downfall—and ultimate redemption—is a tale for another episode

Call to Action

What are your memories to “You Should Be Dancing” by The Bee Gees ? Love to hear if you, like me, feel the need to start dancing whenever you hear the first notes of the song. The beat does it to me every time 😁

Further reading (or should I say watching)

There are a number of interesting video’s/links :

1. They didn’t do video’s at that moment off course. The closest thing to a video for the song is the scene from Saturday Night Fever. J.Travolta/T.Manero’s dance moves are legendary

2. A live version of 1979 : Andy Gibb joins the stage for You Should Be Dancing

3. The Foo Fighters doing Bee Gees… ok ok… it’s only the Dee Gees

4. Live in 1997 : Barry proving he still could do the falsetto live

So You Wanna Hear More ?

I thought you would !

It’s fun to write about music but let’s be honest. Music is made to listen to.

Every week, together with this newsletter, I release a 1 hour beatmix on Mixcloud and Soundcloud. I start with the discussed twelve inch and follow up with 10/15 songs from the same timeframe/genre. The ideal soundtrack for…. Well whatever you like to do when you listen to dance music.

The MIXCLOUD Mix Of The Week

So what’s in this week’s mix ?

This week’s mix showcases the brilliance of “You Should Be Dancing” and its seamless fit with the disco era’s vibe. The track transitions effortlessly into one of 1976’s quintessential Eurodisco hits, Boney M’s “Daddy Cool,” blending the distinct sounds of two disco heavyweights as the break of “You Should Be Dancing” sets the stage.

The heart of this mix, however, lies in the U.S. disco scene, with a strong focus on the Philly sound or Philly Influenced disco with the first hit of Chic, Carol Williams, Double Exposure and the Salsoul Orchestra. The iconic “Earl Young” rhythm—discussed in depth in episode 132 on Love Epidemic and the Trammps—takes center stage

Two standout tracks deserve special mention. First, Cameo’s debut hit, “Find My Way,” offers a glimpse into their early pure disco style, a far cry from the raw funk they later became famous for. Second, I’ve included a rare PAJ Disco mix of Jesse Green’s “Flip.” PAJ Disco, a Montréal-based collective of tape-cutting enthusiasts, reimagined tracks using only commercially available versions, crafting innovative remixes through meticulous tape editing. It’s a lost art, with few surviving examples, as many of their works were only ever distributed as bootlegs. This mix is a nod to their creativity and dedication to the craft.

Enjoy !

Next week, I’ll do something special and introduce the first collab with the incredible Angelica & Beppe of the Italian Disco Stories. We’ll tell the story of an American singer that owes almost everything to Italian composers & dance music. It’s a great story of cross Atlantic cooperation.